Frederick Douglass vs. Karl Marx: KCarl Smith Joins Gary Binford to Debate Liberty, Socialism, and America’s Future

On a recent episode of United Patriots Uprising, host Gary Binford sat down with author, speaker, and political commentator KCarl Smith to discuss his newest book, Douglas vs. Marx: The Battle for America’s Soul. The conversation explored the ideological collision between Frederick Douglass, champion of liberty and personal responsibility, and Karl Marx, architect of socialism and communism — a clash Smith believes defines the cultural and political turmoil of America today.

The premise of Smith’s book is bold: 31 fictional but historically grounded debates between Douglass and Marx, built entirely from their documented writings, speeches, and philosophies. Although the two men never met, Smith notes that Marx did subscribe to Douglass’s North Star newspaper — a detail that underscores how their ideas were already circling each other in the 19th century.

“The fiction stops at the fact they never met,” Smith explains. “The content of the debates is based on what they actually said, wrote, and believed.”

Why Douglass vs. Marx — and Why Now?

Smith says the inspiration for the book came from a growing concern: young Americans no longer understand the value of liberty. He cites economist Thomas Sowell, who famously abandoned Marxism only after hearing a compelling counterargument. Smith wants his book to serve that same purpose for a new generation.

Douglass, he argues, is the perfect messenger. Born into slavery, self‑educated, and ultimately an adviser to five Republican presidents, Douglass embodied the power of individual responsibility and free‑market opportunity. Marx, by contrast, theorized oppression without ever experiencing it.

This contrast, Smith says, is the key to reaching young people:

“You cannot win an argument about the Constitution or the Founders against a man who was a former slave. Experience beats theory every time.”

Inside the 31 Debates

The book’s debates cover issues that remain hotly contested today:

•             Race and identity

•             The role of government

•             Free speech

•             Capitalism vs. socialism

•             Religious liberty

•             Parental rights and education

•             Equality vs. equity

•             The Constitution and the Three‑Fifths Clause

Smith reads excerpts during the interview, including a debate on personal responsibility. Marx argues that the lower classes are trapped by society; Douglass responds:

 “Every person has the ability and the duty to improve themselves. I rose from slavery because I claimed responsibility for my mind, my body, and my actions.”

Another debate tackles modern DEI programs, with Marx defending state‑mandated equity and Douglass countering that liberty cannot coexist with forced redistribution.

Smith emphasizes that Douglass “wins” each debate not because of ideology, but because of lived experience.

Why Douglass Still Threatens the Modern Left

Smith argues that Douglass — along with figures like Booker T. Washington — poses a threat to modern progressive narratives. Douglass’s life story contradicts the idea that Black Americans remain permanently oppressed or dependent on government systems.

He notes that Douglass died with the equivalent of $11 million in today’s dollars, earned through free‑market enterprise — a fact rarely taught in schools.

Smith also recounts how students at a historically Black college used his book to challenge misinformation about the Constitution’s Three‑Fifths Clause, demonstrating how Douglass’s writings still dismantle modern political myths.

Messaging, Identity, and the Conservative Struggle

The conversation also touches on Smith’s earlier work, including Frederick Douglass Republicans and Telling Conservatives the Truth. Smith argues that conservatives consistently lose the messaging war because the left has successfully demonized the word “conservative.”

His solution: adopt the identity of a Frederick Douglass Republican, a term that sparks curiosity and reframes the conversation around liberty rather than labels.

Binford pushes back — he refuses to surrender the word “conservative” — but the exchange highlights a central theme of Smith’s work: effective persuasion requires strategic language.

A Warning About America’s Cultural Shift

Toward the end of the interview, Binford asks whether Smith ever imagined America would reach a point where biological men compete in women’s sports, where officials claim men can get pregnant, or where “my truth” replaces objective reality.

Smith’s answer is blunt: no.

He attributes the shift to what he calls a “reprobate mind,” and argues that reversing course requires families to reclaim conversations about liberty at the dinner table — especially with young people returning from college steeped in Marxist ideology.

His prescription remains the same: use Douglass to defeat Marx.

Where to Find Smith’s Work

Smith’s books — including Douglas vs. Marx, Unchained Ascent, Frederick Douglass Republicans, and Telling Conservatives the Truth are available on Amazon or at his website FDRStore.

Binford closes the episode by praising Smith’s clarity, courage, and commitment to preserving liberty in an era where it is increasingly under attack.

---

Gary Binford, a conservative firebrand and truth-teller who’s shaking the airwaves. With decades of experience as a sports writer for outlets like the New York Daily News and Newsday, Gary brings a journalist’s precision and a patriot’s passion to every episode. His show, a weekly interview-driven juggernaut, tackles the issues tearing at America’s soul—cultural Marxism, election integrity, judicial corruption, and media lies—with guests like Dr. Ben Carson, Monica Crowley, Diamond and Silk, Miranda Devine, Tom Homan, Charlie Kirk, Peter Navarro, Ted Nugent, Kevin Sorbo.

His podcast, launched in 2021, is a battle cry for those fed up with globalist agendas and spineless narratives, delivering unfiltered truth to platforms like Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Rumble, and YouTube.

Watch/subscribe to his YouTube channel. (All episodes are here) 

Gary can also be heard on Radio Influence United Patriots Rising

You can contact Gary via his social Media accounts:

Social Media: X (formerly Twitter): https://x.com/gary_binford 

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/gary.binford

Truth Social:  https://truthsocial.com/@GaryBinford